Dancing With the Stars fans are questioning the judges’ scores after Olympic figure skater Amber Glenn delivered a history-making performance during Season 35’s Disney Night. Although viewers praised her routine with professional partner Pasha Pashkov, the couple received 34 out of 40 points, leaving many fans convinced they deserved higher marks.
Week 8 of the competition aired on November 2, featuring performances inspired by popular Disney movies and Broadway musicals. Glenn and Pashkov took on a Quickstep to “A Star Is Born” from Hercules, earning attention not only for their dancing but also for an unexpected milestone.
During her feedback, judge Carrie Ann Inaba pointed out that Glenn had made DWTS history by taking the lead in the partnership.
“Am I mistaken—is that the first time we’ve had a woman leading a man on this show, in the history of Dancing With the Stars?” Inaba asked. “I do believe it was, so bravo to you for stepping into the power in all the right ways!”
Fans Believe Amber Glenn Deserved Higher Scores
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/amber-glenn-dwts514-11022026-0547dd08ab23413c97240133be7c9858.jpg)
Despite acknowledging the significance of Glenn’s performance, the judges did not give the couple the scores many viewers had hoped for.
Inaba, Derek Hough, guest judge Cynthia Erivo and Bruno Tonioli awarded Glenn and Pashkov three 8s and one 9, bringing their total to 34 out of 40.
The result quickly sparked criticism on Instagram, where fans argued that the routine had been underscored.
“Absolutely underscored,” one viewer wrote.
Another agreed, saying the couple “Deserved AT LEAST all 9s.” A third fan also questioned the judges’ decision, commenting: “Underscored yet again! Shoutout to Pasha for the creativity and letting Amber lead.”
Much of the reaction centered on Pashkov’s choreography and the decision to let Glenn take the lead, making the routine stand out from the usual dynamics between professional dancers and their celebrity partners.
Amber Glenn Advances to the Next Round
Despite the debate over their scores, Glenn and Pashkov successfully advanced to the next round of Season 35.
With Grammys Night scheduled for the following week, the pair will have another opportunity to impress the judges and viewers. After making history on Disney Night, fans will undoubtedly be watching closely to see what Glenn and Pashkov deliver next.
Source: Compiled from various sources