Sharna Burgess is calling for changes to the Dancing With the Stars voting system after Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were shockingly eliminated in the semifinals despite earning perfect scores.
Shum and Johnson were sent home on November 17 after receiving perfect scores for both of their dances. While many fans were surprised by the result, Burgess said she was not completely shocked.
The former DWTS pro shared her thoughts on Instagram Stories on November 20 after a fan asked whether she was surprised to see the pair eliminated.
“Sadly no, I felt it was going to be another shock elimination,” Burgess wrote. She explained that the result was not because she believed they deserved to go home, but because of the strong reactions she had seen online.
Burgess said fan discussions had made it clear that some people were using their votes to eliminate contestants they did not want to see continue, especially dancers with previous experience.
The 41-year-old, who was eliminated with Tyler Cameron on October 27, argued that this has changed the purpose of the voting system.
“It’s so disappointing to see our voting system is now being used by viewers to vote people off instead of voting for your favorite,” she wrote.
Under the current system, fans can cast up to 20 votes for each couple. Burgess suggested bringing that number down and forcing fans to decide how to use a smaller number of votes.
“I say we got [sic] back to y’all only have 10 votes total and you have to figure out how to dish them out,” she said.
Burgess also criticized what she described as the increasingly negative side of online fan discussions. She argued that the current system gives fans more power to influence who leaves the competition instead of simply supporting the couples they like.
“This voting ppl off thing is so insanely negative and not what we are built on and it’s seemingly given fans the chance to manipulate the show. JMO,” she wrote.
Despite the unexpected elimination, Shum appeared to be at peace with the result. Speaking to E! News, he said he did not feel sad and believed he and Johnson had already accomplished what they wanted during their time on the show.

“I oddly feel at ease. I don’t feel sad—it’s really weird,” Shum said. “I kind of felt like we accomplished everything we wanted to.”
With Shum and Johnson gone just before the finale, Burgess’s comments have added another layer to the debate over how much fan voting should influence the outcome of DWTS.