Shirley Ballas could be making more appearances on Dancing With the Stars after her guest judging debut attracted attention during Season 35. According to a report by The U.S. Sun, producers are considering bringing the British ballroom expert back several times next season as part of an effort to refresh the show’s judging panel.
Ballas, who is best known as the head judge on the BBC’s Strictly Come Dancing, joined DWTS as a guest judge during Horror Movie Night. Her appearance brought a different judging style to the American competition, but it also divided viewers. Some fans felt that her scores were too harsh, particularly after she awarded low marks to Tatyana Ali and Julia Stiles.
Her scoring became one of the episode’s major talking points. Ballas gave both Ali and Stiles a score of four, prompting criticism from viewers who believed their performances deserved more generous marks. She defended her approach by explaining that scoring standards differ between Strictly Come Dancing and DWTS, and that a four can carry a different meaning in the British competition.

Despite the negative reactions from some fans, the reported response from producers was more positive. An unnamed insider told The U.S. Sun that Ballas brought fresh energy and tougher marking to the show. The source also said executives were impressed by her work on the summer spinoff Dancing With the Stars: The Next Pro, where she reportedly connected well with audiences.
According to the report, Ballas could appear as a guest judge several times during the next DWTS season if the current plans move forward. The spinoff is also expected to return for a second season, potentially giving her another opportunity to work with the American production.
The possibility of a more permanent role has also been raised. The insider suggested that Ballas could eventually become a full-time judge, although that arrangement would involve a significant scheduling challenge. She remains the head judge on Strictly Come Dancing in the United Kingdom, and the British competition’s live season overlaps with DWTS.

For the moment, there has been no official announcement confirming a new contract or permanent position for Ballas. The current DWTS judging panel of Derek Hough, Carrie Ann Inaba, and Bruno Tonioli is expected to remain in place.
Former DWTS professional Gleb Savchenko has also publicly supported the idea of Ballas joining the panel permanently. He previously praised her ballroom expertise and described her as an outstanding female world champion dancer, adding to the discussion about what her future role on the American show could look like.

Ballas’s return would give DWTS an opportunity to bring back a judge whose first appearance generated strong reactions. Whether audiences will see her several times next season or eventually as a permanent panel member remains uncertain, but producers are reportedly interested in continuing the partnership.
Source: Compiled from various sources
