DWTS Alum Danielle Fishel Calls Out a Double Standard on the Show While Weighing In on the Carrie Ann Inaba Controversy

Danielle Fishel is speaking out about what she believes is a double standard on Dancing With the Stars, saying the judges can be tougher on female celebrities than their male counterparts.

The Boy Meets World alum, who was eliminated during Week 8 of Season 34, recently discussed the issue with two-time Mirrorball Trophy winner Kym Johnson on her Ballroom Breakdown podcast. The pair looked back at Horror Movie Night, which aired on Oct. 27.

That episode featured Shirley Ballas, the legendary Latin dancer and Strictly Come Dancing judge, joining the panel as a guest judge. Ballas handed out several low scores, giving Julia Stiles and Tatyana Ali 4s while Bachelorette alum Tyler Cameron received a 5.

American Idol' Podcast to be Hosted by Danielle Fishel

Johnson admitted she was surprised by Cameron’s score.

“I was surprised that Shirley did give him a five because I thought the girls were better than that,” Johnson said.

Fishel agreed, arguing that Cameron’s performance did not appear stronger than those of Stiles or Ali.

“I also thought that a 5 was generous when she had given Tatyana and Julia a 4,” Fishel said. “There’s no way that this dance was better than what we had seen. And so, if you were going to give the ladies 4s, I feel like this was worthy of a 4 as well.”

Strictly Come Dancing judge's guest appearance on Dancing With the Stars  leaves fans divided | The Independent

For Fishel, the scoring was part of a larger pattern she has noticed throughout the show. She believes male celebrities sometimes receive more leniency from the judging panel.

“I do believe that the judges, all of them, have a tendency to be harder on the women than they are on the male celebs,” Fishel explained. “It could be wrong. But, in my opinion, I think sometimes the men get a pass that the women don’t get.”

DWTS' Disney Night recap: A group dance-off and a tragic elimination

Fishel is not the first person to question whether DWTS judges score men and women differently. Pop Culture Data previously shared an analysis suggesting that judges, including Carrie Ann Inaba, have been kinder to male celebrities than female contestants, which led to backlash from viewers.

Inaba addressed the findings in a 2025 interview with Variety, saying the criticism was “partly true.” Fishel, however, believes the double standard also extends beyond the judges and affects how female judges are treated by the audience.

How DWTS' Carrie Ann Inaba stuck it to nemesis Val Chmerkovskiy on live  show after his shock suspension

“That same can be said for the audience at home, watching the judges,” she said. “The men get away with being able to give a constructive criticism here or there, whereas the women judges, Carrie Ann and the guest judges, they get booed.”

Johnson quickly agreed, saying, “true!”

Fishel then summed up her concerns about how women are treated on the show.

“So in general, I think we see a little bit of unfairness with how women are treated in multiple different ways on the show,” she said.

Related Posts

Alexia Jayy and Her Children Safe After Fire Destroys Their Home and Belongings

Alexia Jayy, who won Season 29 of The Voice earlier this year, is facing a devastating loss after a fire destroyed her family’s belongings at their home…

DWTS Reportedly Wants Shirley Ballas Back Despite Backlash Over Her Strict Scoring

Shirley Ballas could be making more appearances on Dancing With the Stars after her guest judging debut attracted attention during Season 35. According to a report by…

DWTS Star Alan Bersten Lets Slip a Surprising Detail About Ezra and Hailey’s Rumored Romance

Dancing With the Stars professional dancer Alan Bersten has added another playful moment to the growing speculation surrounding Ezra Frech and Hailey Bills. During a recent livestream,…

The Voice Winner Alexia Jayy Suffers Painful Loss as Fire Destroys Many Family Belongings Just Months After Her Career Win

The Voice Season 29 winner Alexia Jayy and her family are facing a painful new start after a house fire destroyed many of their belongings in Mobile,…

Three Times Val Chmerkovskiy Upset DWTS Fans This Season, With His Latest Move Leaving Many Questioning His Actions

Val Chmerkovskiy has faced growing backlash from Dancing With the Stars fans throughout Season 35, with three moments drawing particular attention. His latest move came after his…

The Voice Winner Alexia Jayy Loses Her Home in Devastating Fire as Family Faces New Beginning

Alexia Jayy, winner of Season 29 of The Voice, is facing a difficult new chapter after a fire destroyed much of her family’s home in Mobile, Alabama….