Art of Play is facing another wave of criticism after its public response to Kelly Clarkson’s complaint about her shopping experience failed to settle the dispute. Instead, social media users continued questioning the Brooklyn store’s explanation, with some sharing their own experiences and others claiming the business had not taken responsibility for what happened.
The controversy began on October 10, when Clarkson visited the specialty store, which sells playing cards, puzzles, books and other items. The singer later took to X to describe an interaction that left her feeling judged by a store employee.

Clarkson said she had traveled to Brooklyn because she liked the look of the shop and had several things in mind to purchase. However, she claimed an employee treated her as if she could not afford what she wanted and offered to find her something comparable instead.
“Just drove all the way to Brooklyn to check out this store I thought looked really rad and had a few things in mind to buy and literally was looked at as if I couldn’t afford it and was told he could find something comparable for me,” she wrote.

The singer expressed frustration over the alleged treatment, saying the employee had lost a major sale. She also compared the experience to the famous shopping scene involving Julia Roberts’ character in Pretty Woman, encouraging people to visit Art of Play if they wanted to understand what she meant.
Her post quickly attracted widespread attention, with millions of people seeing the dispute unfold online. The store subsequently faced a flood of negative reviews on its Google and Instagram pages.
Art of Play Explains Its Side of the Story
One day after Clarkson’s complaint, Art of Play published a lengthy Instagram statement explaining what it said had happened during her visit.
According to the business, Clarkson had asked about purchasing an item called Molly, described as a one-of-a-kind singing and dancing bird automaton. The store explained that the unusual piece plays an important role in the magic shows hosted at the shop.
Art of Play maintained that the bird was permanently attached to the wall and was not available for purchase. The business also acknowledged that Clarkson’s description of a negative shopping experience could resonate with people who had ever felt judged while browsing a store.

However, the statement defended the shop’s approach to customers, saying that everyone was welcome whether they planned to buy something or simply wanted to look around.
The business also addressed the intense reaction to Clarkson’s post, expressing surprise that a single celebrity’s complaint had brought so much criticism from people who had never visited.
Art of Play described the experience as surreal and said it hoped to clear things up with Clarkson someday. The statement ended with what appeared to be a reference to her hit song Stronger (What Doesn’t Kill You), adding, “As a talented popular singer once said, ‘What doesn’t kill you makes you stronger.’”
Rather than putting an end to the controversy, however, the response prompted further questions about the store’s account of the incident.
Xem bài viết này trên Instagram
Kelly Clarkson Challenges the Store’s Explanation
Clarkson was quick to respond to the statement, making it clear that she did not accept the store’s claim that the bird was never for sale.
In a follow-up post on October 11, the American Idol winner sarcastically questioned the explanation and accused the business of changing its story.
“Cool, cool. Sure, it wasn’t for sale. That’s the narrative Art of Play is gonna go with,” she wrote.

Clarkson then provided more details about the conversation she said had taken place inside the store. According to her account, she had pointed to a price tag hanging on the wall beneath the item, which was labeled Singing Bird, and asked whether it was available for purchase.
She claimed the employee responded in a condescending tone, telling her that the item was for sale but cost $15,000, before offering to find something comparable.
“So the whole conversation we had when I asked you if it was for sale whilst pointing to the price tag hanging on the wall with the title Singing Bird didn’t happen, as you elevator-eyed me, saying in a condescending tone, ‘Yes, it’s for sale, but it costs 15,000 dollars, so if you’d like me to find something comparable for you, I can,’” Clarkson wrote.

She did not hold back in her assessment of the store’s response, adding, “Okay, cool. So, you’re not only rude, you’re also a liar. Got it.”
Her second post drew millions of views, bringing even more attention to the disagreement. While Art of Play maintained that the bird automaton was not for sale, Clarkson stood by her account of being told it was available at a price of $15,000.
Social Media Users Question the Store’s Response
As the dispute continued, commenters turned their attention to Art of Play’s Instagram statement. Some criticized the wording of the response, while others questioned the claim that the singing bird had never been available for purchase.

One commenter pointed to the alleged price tag, writing, “Girl, stop lying, that bird you’re saying actually has a tag and we saw some photos of it with the price already.”
Another person, Joey Camasta, said they had personally visited the shop months earlier and remembered seeing the item with a price tag.
“I was literally there in August and saw Molly, there was a price tag on it. It most definitely was for sale,” Camasta commented.
The criticism also extended beyond the disagreement over the bird. One Brooklyn resident claimed they had experienced unfriendly behavior from the store’s staff on multiple visits and said the problem had affected their willingness to make purchases.
“I live nearby. You have such a greatly curated shop but the several times I’ve been in I’m met with rude or obnoxious behavior by your staff to us or to other customers. So I leave without buying and return hoping the next time will be different. And several friends have had the same experience,” the commenter wrote.

The account added another dimension to the controversy, suggesting that some customers’ concerns involved their own interactions with staff rather than only Clarkson’s experience.
Still, the comments represent individual accounts and opinions, not independent confirmation of exactly what happened during the singer’s visit.
For now, the central disagreement remains unresolved. Art of Play says Molly is permanently attached to the wall and is not for sale, while Clarkson insists that an employee told her the item cost $15,000 after she pointed to its price tag. With both sides standing by their versions of events, the store’s response has done little to quiet the online debate.