A compliment from Carrie Ann Inaba took an unexpected turn during Dancing With the Stars Grammy Night, leaving fellow judges, contestants and viewers reacting to her choice of words. The judge was praising Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach after their Argentine tango, but her description of their performance quickly became one of the night’s most talked-about moments.
Frech and Karagach opened the November 10 episode with an Argentine tango to Beyoncé’s “Crazy in Love.” Before the performance, Karagach described the close bond she had developed with her celebrity partner, explaining that they were genuinely like brother and sister. She acknowledged that the choreography would require them to step outside that familiar dynamic.
Frech also said he felt comfortable taking on the challenge because he was performing with someone he trusted. Their routine featured an intimate style of choreography, including demanding movements that required Frech to remain centered while dancing with his prosthetic.
The Comment That Changed the Mood
After the performance, Inaba praised Frech’s ability to maintain his balance while communicating the story of the dance. She then described the intimacy by saying that turning his sister into his lover for one night was all right.
The remark prompted laughter from Frech and host Alfonso Ribeiro, but Karagach appeared visibly uncomfortable, furrowing her eyebrows and scrunching her face. Ribeiro responded with a joke about how awkward the phrasing sounded, while Derek Hough also reacted to the unusual comparison.
The moment was brief, but the camera captured enough of the reactions to make it stand out. Bruno Tonioli’s expression also appeared to reflect surprise as the judges’ discussion continued.
Viewers Share Their Reactions

Clips and discussions of the exchange quickly circulated online. Several viewers said they found the comment uncomfortable, particularly because Karagach had just explained that she and Frech shared a sibling-like friendship away from the ballroom.
Some social media users criticized Inaba’s wording and argued that the comparison was unnecessary. Others focused on how the remark was delivered during a live family entertainment program, saying the phrasing caught them off guard.
The reaction added to a season in which the judges’ comments have repeatedly become part of the conversation beyond the scores themselves. Inaba has drawn attention for her feedback on lifts and dance technique, while viewers have also debated the way contestants’ performances are evaluated.

Despite the awkward exchange, Frech and Karagach received three nines from the judges, earning 27 out of 30 points for their Argentine tango. They also advanced to the semifinals, keeping their chance at the Mirrorball Trophy alive.
The episode ended with another major development when Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy were eliminated from Season 35. Their departure came after a night of strong performances and dance-offs, shifting the competition toward the final six couples.

For Frech and Karagach, the score confirmed that their performance had impressed the judges. But Inaba’s unexpected wording ensured that their Grammy Night appearance would be remembered for more than the choreography.
Source: Compiled from various sources