Queen Latifah faced a tough decision during the first night of the Battle Rounds on The Voice Season 30 after pairing two four-chair turns for a performance of Little Big Town’s Girl Crush. Team Queen contestants Kayleigh Mathews and Lillie Kolich impressed all four coaches with their emotional country cover, but only one could advance. Queen chose Kolich, prompting Kelly Clarkson and Riley Green to fight for Mathews in the season’s first Steal.

Queen Latifah Pairs Two Four-Chair Turns for ‘Girl Crush’
Both Mathews and Kolich had earned four-chair turns during the Blind Auditions, making their Battle one of the most challenging decisions for Queen. With help from team advisor Patti LaBelle, the coach encouraged the singers to bring their own strengths to the performance rather than trying to outshine each other.
LaBelle, known for her direct advice, urged the contestants to give their best without worrying about anyone else.
“I swear to you girls, I’m 82 years young. I’m not going to hold in because I’m afraid of insulting someone. What I feel in my heart is necessary to talk about, I talk about it,” LaBelle told them. “I never hold back. Listen. Make sure you’re doing your best. Your best is good enough. That’s all I can do.”
During rehearsals, Queen saw something different in each singer. Mathews brought a spiritual quality to the song, while Kolich stood out for her distinctive flavor and confidence.
“I need them both to bring their A-game,” Queen said. “That will show me who’s ready to take it to the next level.”
Their performance of Girl Crush lived up to the expectations, leaving the coaches impressed by the way both singers handled the emotional song.

All Four Coaches Praise the Performance
Riley Green admitted that he did not envy Queen’s position, especially because both contestants had impressed the coaches during the Blind Auditions.
“It’s not going to be fun, Queen,” he said. “That’s the problem when you get every four-chair turn on your team, you’ve got really talented people going against each other. You won everybody during the Blinds. You have to deal with this now.”
Kelly Clarkson was equally enthusiastic, revealing that she had heard many versions of the Little Big Town hit but considered this one her favorite.
“I’ve heard this song done a lot. Y’all, that was my favorite. So gorgeous,” Clarkson told the singers.
Queen also praised the performance, saying she felt honored to witness their interpretation of the song. However, she still had to choose which contestant would continue on her team.
In the end, Queen selected Kolich, explaining that she was “so special and unique.”

Kelly Clarkson and Riley Green Fight to Steal Kayleigh Mathews
Mathews’ elimination from Team Queen did not last long. When host Carson Daly asked whether she wanted to say anything to her coach, Clarkson interrupted by hitting her Steal button.
“Who cares about her?” Clarkson joked before making her pitch for the singer.
But Clarkson was not the only coach hoping to bring Mathews onto a new team. Green also pressed his button, turning the moment into a competition between the two coaches.
Clarkson immediately pointed out that Green was wearing a cowboy hat and argued that she had acted first. She reminded Mathews of the excitement she must have felt when Queen originally chose her during the Blind Auditions, promising that she could help her experience that feeling again.
“I have won a competition! I promise you I can do it,” Clarkson declared.

Green kept his pitch short and confident, suggesting that the other coaches did not want Mathews on his team because they knew he could win the season with her.
“They don’t want you on my team, because they know we’re going to win The Voice. I don’t blame them for that,” he said.
The double Steal marked a major moment in Season 30’s first Battle episode, giving Mathews another chance to continue her journey after losing her original team spot.
However, viewers still had to wait to learn whether Mathews would choose Clarkson or Green as her new coach. Her decision was set to be revealed when The Voice returned on Tuesday, October 13, on NBC, with the episode available to stream on Peacock the following day.