After six incredible seasons, The Handmaid’s Tale has finally come to an end, and I couldn’t be happier with Janine Lindo’s (Madeline Brewer) ending. Although The Handmaid’s Tale is based on Margaret Atwood’s 1985 novel of the same name, the scale and scope of the novel cannot match 6 seasons of television. Characters like Janine Lindo (Madeline Brewer) changed wildly in the transition from book to series. In the novel, Janine is so beaten down at the Red Center that she becomes a submissive favorite of the Aunts.

Although Janine has a daughter in The Handmaid’s Tale novel, that child is designated a “shredder” and does not survive. In Margaret Atwood’s novel, Janine’s life is a tragedy from beginning to end, and Janine’s characterization in Hulu’s series is still tragic but undeniably more uplifting. In the TV series, Janine fights back against Gillead, and her daughter, named Angela by the Commanders and Charlotte by Janine, lives. In the bleak world of Gilead, Janine’s fate is one of the only genuinely hopeful aspects of The Handmaid’s Tale’s finale.

Janine Reuniting With Her Daughter Was Perfect

It’s A Great Scene And A Full Circle Moment

As The Handmaid’s Tale‘s finale concludes, Aunt Lydia (Ann Dowd) and Naomi Lawrence (Ever Carradine) reunite Janine with her daughter, Charlotte. At that moment, Janine’s story finally came full circle. With the reunion of Janine and Charlotte, it became clear that, even if the other aspects of The Handmaid’s Tale‘s ending were ambiguous, at least one character would have a genuinely happy ending.

Janine first gave birth to Charlotte back in The Handmaid’s Tale season 1, and she never stopped fighting for her daughter. Charlotte and Janine reuniting years later meant that The Handmaid’s Tale had a beautiful full-circle moment at the end. Ultimately, a weeping Janine embraces her daughter, and the two of them travel to safety on US soil. Janine’s reunion with Charlotte means that both of them are finally at peace, and I would not change a single detail.

Janine Not Having A Happy Ending Would’ve Been Too Cruel, Even For The Handmaid’s Tale

If Anyone Deserved A Happy Ending, It Was Janine

Image via Hulu

Image via Hulu

Image via Hulu

One reason that I am especially grateful that Janine was reunited with Charlotte is that the alternative would have been too cruel. While every class of woman in The Handmaid’s Tale is undeniably oppressed, Janine’s backstory is particularly tragic. Before Gilead, Janine was gang-raped as a young woman. She had her eye ripped out as punishment at the Red Center, was forced to endure years of sexual violence as a Handmaid, and experienced the further rape and exploitation of working as a Jezebel.

Janine’s biography reads as a decades-long litany of some of the most horrific violence and tragedy that a human can experience. By The Handmaid’s Tale season 6, one of the few goals that Janine has left is getting her daughter back. If The Handmaid’s Tale hadn’t let Janine and Charlotte reunite, then Janine would have suffered yet another blow at the hands of Gilead.

While it is true that The Handmaid’s Tale is a cautionary tale, it is by no means hopeless or nihilistic. If Janine had been kept from her daughter in the finale, all of the hopeful messaging about resistance and rebellion in The Handmaid’s Tale would have been undercut by Janine’s tragedy. The only good ending was a reunion between Janine and Charlotte, and I am so glad that The Handmaid’s Tale let us share in their joy in the end.

The Handmaid’s Tale Even Found A Moment Of Redemption For Naomi

Even A Wife Can Find Redemption

The cherry on top of Janine and Charlotte’s ending is the role that Naomi played in their reunion. Although Naomi, as a Wife, was in an antagonistic position towards Janine and the Handmaids for most of the show, Naomi has consistently been at her most human when interacting with Charlotte, or, as she calls her, Angela. The Handmaid system in Gilead meant that Naomi was Angela’s adopted mother – she may not have been a perfect parent, but it is clear that Naomi did care for the little girl.

Naomi tells Charlotte, “you need to be safe,” and, in that moment, she explains her actions. By the finale of The Handmaid’s Tale, Naomi has gone from a Wife to a widow, and she has watched a revolution rock her country. Naomi cannot keep Charlotte safe in the remains of Gilead, but the child has a chance in the United States with Janine. By helping Janine and Charlotte, Naomi shows that, despite buying into a brutally cruel and misogynistic system, her humanity is intact. While the ending doesn’t excuse Naomi’s earlier actions, it undeniably offers her a sliver of redemption.

Janine’s Ending Was Bittersweet

Charlotte Got Out because Hannah Couldn’t

The Handmaid’s Tale was never going to give us an unequivocally happy ending, however, and Janine’s happy ending is contemporaneous with June Osborne’s (Elizabeth Moss) final tragedy. While Janine does get her daughter back, June’s daughter, Hannah (Jordanna Blake), is still in Gilead. That loss is written plain across June’s face when Aunt Lydia and Naomi emerge with Charlotte. Of course, we, the audience, had a pretty good reason to suspect that Hannah was never going to get out of Gilead.

Related

What Happens To Hannah & Nichole After The Handmaid’s Tale

Hannah and Nichole are two of the main characters in The Testaments, so here is what happens to them after The Handmaid’s Tale and before the sequel.

1

Hulu has announced a sequel series to The Handmaid’s Tale based on Margaret Atwood’s 2019 novel, The Testaments. In The Testaments, Hannah is a main character, and she’s still in Gilead. If Hulu wants to stay true to Atwood’s narrative, then June and Hannah could not be reunited. That massive loss hangs over everyone’s heads, even as it is wonderful to see Janine and Charlotte together again. June’s tragedy makes Janine’s ending a bittersweet victory, and, for a series as rich and complex as The Handmaid’s Tale, I wouldn’t have it any other way.